cover image
Laborhutt Staff
June 21, 2024

Local Movers vs. U-Haul: Which is Cheaper for Your Move?

Are you planning a move soon and feeling overwhelmed by all the details? You're not alone. One big decision is whether to hire local movers or rent a U-Haul and move yourself. This choice can really affect your moving experience, especially if you're on a budget. Let's look at the costs and benefits of each option to help you decide. 

"Moving can be very stressful, but choosing the right option between local movers and a DIY move can save you time, money, and stress."

From hidden fees to the physical effort involved, each choice has its challenges and perks. Understanding these will help you pick the most cost-effective and suitable option for your move.

Initial Cost Comparison: Local Movers vs. U-Haul

Movers vs U-Haul Cost comparison

Let's dive deeper into what these costs entail for both options.

Local Movers: The cost of hiring local movers can range from $500 to $1,500. This depends on factors like the distance of the move, how much stuff you have, and any extra services like packing. While the cost might seem high, remember that this includes labor. Professionals will handle the heavy lifting, saving you time and effort.

U-Haul Rental: Renting a U-Haul truck is generally cheaper, costing between $80 and $300+. This usually covers the truck rental, basic mileage, and fuel. But you also need to pay for things like insurance, moving equipment, and extra mileage. Plus, you'll be doing all the loading, driving, and unloading yourself, which can be tiring and time-consuming.

When deciding, consider both the costs and the value of your time and effort. If you're on a tight budget and okay with a DIY move, renting a U-Haul might be the way to go. But if you want to avoid stress and physical work, hiring movers could be worth the extra cost.

Use cost comparison tools and budget calculators to estimate your total moving costs. Think about the convenience versus cost to choose the best option for your move.

Time vs. Money: Which Option Saves You More?

U-Haul vs movers feature comparisons

hen deciding between local movers and a U-Haul rental, cost is just one of the factors to consider. Local movers charge around $800 for a convenient and low-stress experience. Your time commitment is minimal, usually just 4-6 hours. This fee often includes insurance, so your belongings are protected.

A U-Haul rental is cheaper, about $100 on average. However, this option requires more of your time and effort. Packing and moving can take 1-2 days and involve a lot of physical work. Plus, it's more stressful since you handle all the planning. If you choose insurance, expect extra costs.

Your choice depends on what you value more: saving money or saving time and energy. Local movers offer a hassle-free experience at a higher price, while U-Haul rentals are budget-friendly but require more work. Think about what matters to you and pick the option that fits your needs.

Real-life Cost Comparisons: Local Movers Vs. U-Haul

Real-life cost comparison

The table shows the costs of hiring local movers versus renting a U-Haul. Let's break it down:

Base Cost: Local movers cost between $500 and $1500. Renting a U-Haul is cheaper, at $50 to $150 per day. A U-Haul is more affordable if you can move quickly.

Gas and Insurance: Local movers include gas and insurance in their price. With a U-Haul, you’ll pay extra for gas ($100 - $300) and insurance ($30 - $50 per day). These costs can add up, especially for long or multi-day moves.

Labor: Local movers include labor in their price. With a U-Haul, you might need to spend $100 - $200 for help unless you do all the lifting yourself.

Overall Cost for an Average Move (100 Miles): Including all expenses, local movers will cost between $800 and $2000. A U-Haul rental ranges from $350 to $700. While a U-Haul might seem cheaper at first, consider the physical effort and time needed to move everything yourself.

In conclusion, while renting a U-Haul usually costs less, the added work and possible hidden costs might make local movers a more convenient choice, especially for larger or more complex moves.

Fuel Costs: Local Movers vs. U-Haul

Fuel costs can greatly affect your budget. Hiring local movers usually means fuel costs are included in the price, which is helpful if you're moving far or gas prices are high.

Renting a U-Haul means you pay for the gas yourself. U-Haul charges per mile, and a 26-foot truck gets about 10 miles per gallon. For long distances, these fuel costs can add up quickly. Don't forget tolls and extra fees, which are not included in the rental price.

Local movers might seem more expensive at first, but they can save you money on fuel, especially when gas prices are high. Plus, you don’t need to worry about the miles you drive. If fuel costs are a big concern, hiring local movers might be the cheaper option.

Insurance and Liability: Local Movers vs. U-Haul

When it comes to insurance and liability, local movers and U-Haul offer different options. Local movers usually include basic liability coverage. If your belongings get damaged, the company typically compensates you, although it might be limited.

U-Haul offers extra insurance that you can buy. This includes coverage for the truck and your belongings, plus extra liability protection. Buying this insurance increases your costs but gives you peace of mind.

It's important to read the details. Local movers might offer minimal compensation per pound, which might not be enough for valuable items. And with U-Haul, knowing what each insurance plan covers can save you from extra costs later.

U-Haul often requires a deposit, and any vehicle damage can reduce this deposit. Local movers usually don’t have deposits but may charge extra for stairs, long carries, or tough moves.

In short, if you want less personal responsibility, hiring local movers may be better. If you like full control and managing insurance yourself, renting a U-Haul could be a good, though more complex, option.

What factors affect the cost of hiring local movers?

Several factors can affect the cost of hiring local movers. One key factor is the distance of the move. Local movers usually charge by the hour, so the farther you move, the more you'll pay in labor costs.

The volume and weight of your belongings are also important. Moving a one-bedroom apartment costs less than moving a fully-furnished multi-bedroom house. More staff or special equipment might be needed for heavy or bulky items, driving up the cost.

An important factor is the time of year. Moving during peak seasons like summer or the end of the month can be more expensive due to high demand. Moving during off-peak times can save you money.

Don't forget about the cost of extra services like packing and unpacking. While these can save you time and stress, they add to the overall cost. If you can, packing yourself is a budget-friendly alternative.

Finally, think about the cost of insurance and liability. Ensuring your items are protected while in transit is crucial. Some companies include basic coverage, but you might need to pay more for comprehensive insurance for peace of mind.

What factors affect the cost of renting a U-Haul?

When it comes to renting a U-Haul, several variables come into play. First, truck size is a major cost determinant. U-Haul offers a range of sizes, from small vans to large 26-foot trucks. Naturally, the larger the truck, the higher the rental cost.

Distance and duration also significantly impact the final price. U-Haul costs are typically divided into two categories: in-town and one-way moves. In-town rentals are usually cheaper but charge by the mile, whereas one-way moves offer a flat rate with a higher upfront cost, which might include a certain number of miles. Additional miles over the included amount will cost extra.

Another factor to consider is the time of year. Moving during peak seasons, such as summer, can drive up rates due to higher demand. If you have a flexible schedule, moving during off-peak times can save you money.

Fuel costs are often overlooked but can add up quickly. Larger trucks consume more fuel, so plan accordingly. It's important to return the truck with the same fuel level you received it to avoid additional charges.

A variation in pick-up and drop-off locations might also affect costs. Returning the truck to a different location than where you picked it up can incur extra fees.

Lastly, don't forget about additional equipment and services. Need a dolly or moving pads? These come at an extra cost. And if you're considering adding insurance or damage protection, this will also contribute to the overall expense.

By carefully assessing these factors, you can better estimate the total cost of renting a U-Haul and find the most budget-friendly option for your move.

Welcome to!

Looking for moving help? Laborhutt makes moving furniture & heavy items a breeze by connecting you with neighbors who have pickup trucks. Message a neighbor near you and save time and money.